The Freedom to Be Jewish
I’ve written a lot in my Ted Talks about the magic of a technology-free summer at Herzl Camp. About kids being kids. About the freedom to live without phones, social media, likes, followers, and all the pressures that come with being connected to the rest of the world 24 hours a day.
And I’ve written about what happens when you take all of that away. Kids talk to one another. They laugh and they sing. They build friendships, figure things out for themselves, and discover that they don’t have to be the coolest kid in the room. They just have to be themselves.
But a recent study from the Anti-Defamation League and Boundless, along with a conversation I heard on Dan Senor’s Call Me Back podcast, has me thinking about another, perhaps even more important, benefit of our technology-free environment.
The ADL study found that young Americans struggle to recognize antisemitism on social media, particularly when it’s wrapped in contemporary rhetoric about Israel and Zionism. Gen Z had an even harder time recognizing it than millennials.
Think about that for a moment.
Our young people are growing up in a world where antisemitism doesn’t always look like the antisemitism we learned about in history books. Sometimes it’s subtle. Sometimes it’s packaged as social justice. Sometimes it’s buried in a meme or a video shared thousands of times. And sometimes, before a young person has had the opportunity to fully appreciate their own Jewish identity, someone on a screen is already telling them what being Jewish, or being a Zionist, should mean.
On Call Me Back, Dan and his guests made an observation that really struck me: Too many young Jews today are experiencing the downside of Judaism without ever getting to experience the upside. They’re exposed to the hatred, the rhetoric, the politics, and the noise, but not nearly enough of the beauty, joy, wisdom, and extraordinary sense of belonging that come with being Jewish.
That’s what makes the Herzl experience so incredibly important.
For weeks at a time, our campers are removed from that noise. No algorithms telling them what to think. No comment sections challenging their identity. No social media feeds shaping their understanding of Israel or Judaism.
Instead, they’re surrounded by a community where being Jewish is celebrated. Where loving Israel is part of the fabric of daily life. Where Israeli counselors aren’t headlines or political arguments, but friends, mentors, and people they come to love. Where Shabbat is something you experience with your arms around your friends, singing at the top of your lungs, rather than something you scroll past on a screen.
And where being a proud Jew isn’t a statement you have to make. It’s simply who you are.
Every day at Herzl, we sing Hatikvah, Israel’s national anthem, whose words remind us, Od lo avdah tikvateinu – we have not yet lost our hope. Think about the power of hundreds of young Jews singing those words together. Not because someone told them what political position to take, but because they feel connected to something so much bigger than themselves. A people, a history, and a future that have endured for thousands of years.
I think about our older campers, who eventually rip up their proverbial “cool cards” and embrace everything that makes Herzl so magic. The songs, the traditions, the ruach, the silliness, and that extraordinary sense of belonging. And I think about our younger campers watching them, learning that it’s not just okay to be Jewish, it’s amazingly wonderful.
Another point from the podcast stayed with me. We spend so much time talking about the politics surrounding Judaism that we sometimes forget to talk about what Judaism actually offers us, particularly in a world where our children are struggling with anxiety, loneliness, and the pressure to fit in.
At Herzl, we don’t need to teach 10-year-olds politics. We teach them kindness, compassion, inclusion, responsibility, and what it means to be part of a community. We give them the space to develop confidence, build meaningful friendships, and understand that they matter to something bigger than themselves.
Judaism doesn’t just help us become better Jews. It helps us become better human beings. And in many ways, that’s Herzl Camp in a nutshell.
Of course, we can’t shelter our kids from antisemitism forever. Nor should we. They need to understand it, recognize it, and know how to respond. That’s why our conversations about Jewish identity, Israel, Zionism, and antisemitism matter so much.
But I believe there is an order to all of this. Before we ask our kids to defend who they are, we need to give them the opportunity to fall in love with who they are.
That’s what happens at Herzl.
We aren’t simply giving kids a break from their phones. We’re giving them the time, space, relationships, and experiences to develop a Jewish identity grounded in joy, knowledge, friendship, pride, and a genuine connection to Israel.
And we need to remember that this is a long game. The Jewish story has never been a straight line. There has been pain, loss, setbacks, and more than a few small defeats along the way. There will undoubtedly be more. But there has also been extraordinary resilience, renewal, joy, and an unwavering commitment to the generations that follow.
When you send your child to Jewish summer camp, you’re putting our future into training camp. Not to prepare them for a fight, but to prepare them for a lifetime. To give them the confidence to stand tall, the strength to weather the inevitable challenges, the compassion to care for others, and the understanding that they’re part of a story much bigger than themselves.
We aren’t preparing them to win every argument or every battle. We’re helping them understand why it’s worth staying in the game. Because ultimately, it’s in their hands to carry forward the pride, the values, the traditions, and the message of a people who have never lost hope. And it’s our responsibility to make sure they’re ready, not just to carry that legacy, but to love it, live it, and pass it on.
Eventually, the summer ends. The phones turn back on. The algorithms return. And so does the noise. But through our work, our hope is that something has changed.
That when our campers encounter antisemitism, they have the confidence to recognize it. That when someone tries to define Zionism for them, they have the knowledge and personal experiences to think critically and form their own understanding. And that when the world challenges their Jewish identity, they remember the community where that identity was never in question.
The Jewish people have been described as a phoenix, rising again and again despite those who would destroy us. I love that image. But I also think about the young birds who will carry that story forward. At Herzl, we’re helping them find their wings, grounded in a history they understand, a community they love, and a hope that has never been lost.
We often talk about the gift of a technology-free childhood.
I think, especially today, we’re giving our kids something even greater.
The freedom to discover who they are as Jews, before the world tries to tell them who they should be.
And in today’s world, I can’t think of many gifts more important than that.
Tommy
